The size of the rooms are expected to be small. The problems and how they are addressed become a bigger issue.
To get it out of the way, the number one complaint my wife has was the translucent wall between the bedroom and the bathroom, with the toilet next to the this. The image of whomever is on the throne shows through to the bedroom.
The room we were initally give was appointed well enough to suit our needs, and fulfilled my request to be away from the noise of Houston St. Unfortunately the thermostat was broken. We initially compained about the blowing heat at 2pm, but returned at 7pm to find it still a problem, and the room at about 85 degrees F.
Since we had dinner reservations, we made a mad scramble to move to the room that they now furnished us with, now that they conceeded that the thermostat couldn't be addressed. Unfortunately, this new room was smaller, faced Houston St. and had the stairwell outside the door, which conveyed all the hallway's noise easily into the room.
They did adjust our rate to reflect the small room size, but I think if they had tried to make a change 5 hours before, perhaps we could have been better accommodated.
The final issue was on our day of departure. We checked our bags with the desk, so we could spend the afternoon in the area before leaving for the airport. We returned 15 minutes before our car was due to arrive, but the hotel could not locate our luggage. 30 minutes later, after phone calls to the staff that was on duty but no longer there, and extensive searches, which included both rooms, various closets, and their storage areas, they found our bags, and we escaped.
This hotel is a nice discount over the area's other boutique hotels, but if you want to stay in that area for those rates, I would go with the Hojo on the next block first. Otherwise, pay the premium for the quality.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.